October 20, 1996 — WWF In Your House 11: Buried Alive. The Undertaker finally won his war with Mankind by burying him in a real grave dug beside the entrance ramp. Then the show’s closing image became one of the most replayed in wrestling history: a purple-gloved hand bursting up through the dirt.
The Setup
The summer of 1996 belonged to the darkest feud in the WWF. At SummerSlam, Paul Bearer — the Undertaker’s urn-carrying manager of six years — turned on his own Deadman, siding with the deranged Mankind and costing The Phenom their Boiler Room Brawl. From that night on, the rivalry was personal, violent, and steeped in gothic horror.
The WWF needed a match as macabre as the feud. So for October’s In Your House pay-per-view — held at the Market Square Arena in Indianapolis — they dug an actual open grave at the top of the entrance ramp and dared two monsters to put each other in it. Win by burying your opponent alive. Simple. Unhinged. Perfect.
The Burial
Undertaker and Mankind brawled through the ringside area with chairs, ring steps, and shovels before the fight migrated to the graveyard set. The Deadman hit the Tombstone in the ring, hauled Mankind to the grave on his shoulders, survived a Mandible Claw scare, and finally chokeslammed Mankind into the hole. Dirt hit the body. The bell rang. The Undertaker had won.
And then the show went sideways — deliberately.
A masked man — Terry Gordy, debuting that night as The Executioner — blindsided Undertaker with a shovel, dragged Mankind out of the grave, and dumped The Deadman in instead. Heel after heel — Goldust, Crush, Bradshaw, Triple H — poured out to help pile the dirt on. The pay-per-view ended with the WWF’s biggest star buried under a mountain of soil while Paul Bearer cackled over the grave.
Then the lightning struck. Thunder rolled through the arena, a bolt hit the tombstone, and the Undertaker’s purple-gloved hand shot up out of the dirt as the screen went black.
“He’s alive! The Undertaker is alive! The Undertaker lives!”
Why It Still Matters
The first Buried Alive match was a gimmick that had no right to work — and a finale that worked too well. The hand-through-the-dirt shot became one of the defining visuals of the era, endlessly replayed on highlight reels and video packages. Fittingly, it was also the last appearance of the Undertaker’s classic purple-glove look, closing one chapter of the Deadman as the next one began.
Behind the scenes, the burial was a logistical nightmare — years later, JBL (then Justin “Hawk” Bradshaw, one of the shovel crew) called trying to fill the grave in real time “an absolute disaster.” On screen, though, nobody cared. The image was perfect: you can bury The Undertaker, but you cannot kill him.
Same-night footnote: Sycho Sid beat Vader to earn a WWF Championship shot — a shot he’d cash in at Survivor Series to win his first world title.
Sources: WWF In Your House 11: Buried Alive, Oct 20, 1996; event and match history via Wikipedia, PWInsider and TJR Wrestling’s “On This Day” archives; match retrospective via Wrestling Profiles and WhatCulture.
Leave a Reply