Our Summerslam 2026 Night 1 & 2 Picks

SummerSlam Predictions: The Spotlight Crew Makes Their Picks for Both Nights

It all comes down to this! The championship is on the line for our last PLE of the season, and will Jeremy retain the title, or is a new champion lurking?

SummerSlam is here, and the Squared Circle Spotlight crew has officially locked in their predictions for both nights of WWE’s biggest event of the summer. While everyone agrees on a few major matches, several championship bouts and bonus questions have the panel divided, making this one of our toughest prediction contests yet.


Night 1 Predictions

Night 1 features three unanimous picks, as every member of the panel is backing CM Punk, Oba Femi, and Gunther to pick up victories.

The biggest disagreement comes in the Women’s Championship match. Joe is the lone panelist sticking with Iyo Sky, while Kathy, Charlie, and Jeremy all believe Liv Morgan leaves SummerSlam with the title.

The six-person tag also has the panel split. Joe is taking LA Knight, Solo Sikoa & Royce Keys, while everyone else is riding with The Bloodline.

Charlie is once again the wildcard in the women’s tag match, picking The Bellas & Paige, while the rest of the crew believes Fatal Influence gets the win.

Night 1 Picks

MatchJoeKathyCharlieJeremy
CM Punk vs. Cody RhodesCM PunkCM PunkCM PunkCM Punk
Brock Lesnar vs. Oba FemiOba FemiOba FemiOba FemiOba Femi
Liv Morgan vs. Iyo SkyIyo SkyLiv MorganLiv MorganLiv Morgan
Gunther vs. Nick AldisGuntherGuntherGuntherGunther
The Bloodline vs. Solo Sikoa, LA Knight & Royce KeysLA Knight, Solo Sikoa & Royce KeysThe BloodlineThe BloodlineThe Bloodline
Fatal Influence vs. The Bellas & PaigeFatal InfluenceFatal InfluenceThe Bellas & PaigeFatal Influence

Bonus Predictions

QuestionJoeKathyCharlieJeremy
Opening MatchBloodline MatchBloodline MatchOba vs. BrockGunther vs. Aldis
Main EventOba vs. BrockPunk vs. CodyPunk vs. CodyOba vs. Brock

Night 2 Predictions

Night 2 is where things really get interesting.

Three of the four panelists believe Roman Reigns successfully retains the World Heavyweight Championship, while Kathy is the lone member backing Seth Rollins.

The Interim Women’s Championship Ladder Match has no clear favorite. Joe and Kathy are backing Chelsea Green, while Charlie and Jeremy are riding with Charlotte Flair.

The No. 1 Contender’s Match sees Joe and Jeremy siding with Finn Bálor, while Kathy and Charlie are backing Sami Zayn.

The United States Championship is split evenly between Baron Corbin and Trick Williams, while the Intercontinental Championship is another close call with three panelists predicting Chad Gable dethrones Penta.

Night 2 Picks

MatchJoeKathyCharlieJeremy
World Heavyweight Championship – Roman Reigns vs. Seth RollinsRoman ReignsSeth RollinsRoman ReignsRoman Reigns
Interim WWE Women’s Championship Ladder MatchChelsea GreenChelsea GreenCharlotte FlairCharlotte Flair
Finn Bálor vs. Sami ZaynFinn BálorSami ZaynSami ZaynFinn Bálor
Danhausen vs. Dominik MysterioDominik MysterioDanhausenDanhausenDanhausen
United States Championship – Trick Williams vs. Baron CorbinBaron CorbinBaron CorbinTrick WilliamsTrick Williams
Intercontinental Championship – Penta vs. Chad GableChad GableChad GableChad GableChad Gable

Bonus Predictions

QuestionJoeKathyCharlieJeremy
Outside Interference in the Main Event?NoYesYesYes
Combined Spears & Curb Stomps4557

Final Thoughts

SummerSlam is shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable prediction contests we’ve had all year. While the crew is confident in stars like CM Punk, Oba Femi, and Gunther, several championship matches are completely up for debate.

Will Jeremy continue his reign as the Squared Circle Spotlight Prediction Champion, or will one of the challengers finally knock him off the top?

Drop your own SummerSlam predictions in the comments and let us know which matches you’re most excited to watch!

Leave a comment